Suffredin- For a Better Cook County  
 

Accountability
Forest Preserves
Public Safety
Cook County Budget
Forest Pres. Budget
Property Tax Appeal
Health & Hospitals
Land Bank Authority
Policy Resolutions
Unsung Heroine

 

   
 
   
   
 
   
     
  Office phone numbers:  
   
 
 

Search current and proposed Cook County Legislation in Larry's exclusive legislative library.

   
 

The Cook County Code of Ordinances are the current laws of Cook County.

   
  Last year more people used the County's forest preserves than visited Yellowstone National Park.
   
     
     
     



Sheriff: Biased judge should quit jail beating case

Monday, February 27, 2006
Chicago Sun-Times
by ABDON M. PALLASCH Legal Affairs Reporter

In a rare and risky move, Cook County Sheriff Michael Sheahan has accused a federal judge of bias and asked him to take himself off a case against Sheahan.
Federal judges decide whether to recuse themselves, and almost always rule against recusal. Then the judge holds in his or her hands the fate of someone who has accused him or her of bias.
Judges are often accused of being harder on the attorneys on one side of a long-running case than the other, but experts say that is often because the judge has grown tired of stalling or other alleged antics by that side.
Laying groundwork for appeal?
In this case, Sheahan and 12 jail officials were sued three years ago by two jail guards who say they were harassed after they reported other guards took part in a mass beating of prisoners in 2000.
Judge Ruben Castillo has lost patience with Sheahan's attorneys for, among other things, allegedly failing to keep the sheriff from leaving a six-hour deposition.
Matthew Piers, attorney for the two guards, Roger Fairley and Rich Gackowski, says Sheahan arrived late, took long breaks to confer with his attorneys, and left before the six hours were up. Sheahan said he got there early, answered all Piers' questions, and left after six hours.
Castillo sided with Piers and ordered Sheahan to go back for another two hours.
"This is what happens when competent counsel don't involve themselves in discovery," Castillo said. "I consider what occurred there to be less than professional."
Sheahan's 21-page affidavit and the 20-page submissions of his 12 co-defendant jail officials are full of quotes from Castillo slamming lawyers for their side, asking why they don't settle the case for the good of Cook County taxpayers, who so far have paid nearly $1 million to Sheahan and the officials' lawyers.
"While this is not a public corruption case, anytime taxpayer money is wasted, that to me is the equivalent of corruption," Castillo said, noting that he is a taxpayer.
Quotes like that prove Castillo is biased against them, Sheahan says.
In his response Friday, Piers said Sheahan's lawyers earned Castillo's barbs by filing a lot of bad motions.
"They can't seriously think they're going to get him to recuse himself because of this silly motion saying 'We don't like you and we think you don't like us,'" said defense attorney and former federal prosecutor Patrick Cotter. But Cotter said motions for recusal are often used for other purposes.
To try to get the guards to settle for a lower amount -- $3.8 million is the latest demand county officials balk at -- Sheahan could use Castillo's expected refusal to take himself off the case Wednesday as grounds for an appeal, delaying any payoff for the guards, Cotter said.
"Or it could be what some lawyers refer to as 'the shot across the bow' at the judge -- make him a little self-conscious about doing it, hope he'll back off a little bit," Cotter said.
Favoritism implied
Sheahan and the other men say Castillo was regional counsel for the Mexican-American Legal Defense and Education Fund 15 years ago and Piers -- who took over a year and a half ago as the third lawyer for Gackowski and Fairley -- was on MALDEF's board eight years ago. Castillo also ruled in Piers' favor in a different case nine years ago, Sheahan argues.
That all shows bias, Sheahan says.
The most similar recent case came last year when the federal appellate court took a dispute out of U.S. District Judge James Holderman's court after U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald said Holderman was acting in a biased way against prosecutors.
But judges and lawyers were hard-pressed to name any case in which a judge recused himself because of an accusation of bias, or in which the appellate court reversed a case because a judge refused to recuse himself or herself.
"The chance of success is remote," said Northwestern University Law professor Steven Lubet. "Winning a case on appeal based on a judge's decision on recusal is even more unusual."



Recent Headlines

Illinois Medical District to get largest ambulance garage in Cook County
Wednesday, September 20, 2017
Crain's Chicago Business

Cook County sweetened beverage sales continue to decline
Tuesday, September 19, 2017
Chicago Sun-Times

New bond court rules take effect, but not much of an effect
Tuesday, September 19, 2017
Chicago Sun-Times

Bond court gets underway in Cook County with different judges, new guidelines
Monday, September 18, 2017
Chicago Tribune

Harwood Heights adds retail theft as ordinance violation
Monday, September 18, 2017

Cook County’s Homeland Security interim chief resigns
Monday, September 18, 2017
Chicago Sun-Times

Cook County's social worker for the dead helps the unclaimed find final resting places
Monday, September 18, 2017
Chicago Tribune

After legal challenges, Cook County's court for unwed parents quietly goes away
Monday, September 18, 2017
Chicago Tribune

Welcome to Cook County, Mayor Bloomberg. You're getting played on the soda tax.
Friday, September 15, 2017
Chicago Tribune

Evans reshuffles bond court; meet the ‘Pretrial Division’
Friday, September 15, 2017
Chicago Daily Law Bulletin

Editorial: The Cook County Board's legacy: Killing Cook County jobs
Friday, September 15, 2017
Chicago Tribune

If the soda tax were out of sight, would it be out of mind?
Friday, September 15, 2017
Chicago Tribune

Cook County Board delays showdown over soda tax until October 10, and other Chicago news
Thursday, September 14, 2017
Chicago Reader

City reports record number of Chicagoans with health insurance
Thursday, September 14, 2017
Crain's Chicago Business

Morning Spin: 10 key numbers in Cook County soda tax repeal debate
Wednesday, September 13, 2017
Chicago Tribune

Four weeks to kill the soda tax
Wednesday, September 13, 2017
Chicago Tribune

CPS inspector: High school at Cook County Jail phonied up attendance
Wednesday, September 13, 2017
Chicago Sun-Times

CPS Watchdog: School In Cook County Jail Falsified Attendance, Credit Rates
Wednesday, September 13, 2017
WTTW Chicago Tonight

Morning Spin: 10 key numbers in Cook County soda tax repeal debate
Wednesday, September 13, 2017
Chicago Tribune

EDITORIAL: What’s to be done when a dead man gets class credit?
Wednesday, September 13, 2017
Chicago Sun-Times

all news items

Paid for by Larry Suffredin and not at taxpayer expense. A Haymarket Production.
^ TOP