Suffredin- Changing County Government  
 

Accountability
Forest Preserves
Public Safety
Cook County Budget
Forest Pres. Budget
Property Tax Appeal
Health & Hospitals
Land Bank Authority
Policy Resolutions
Unsung Heroine

 

   
 
   
   
 
   
     
  Office phone numbers:  
   
 
 

The Cook County Code of Ordinances are the current laws of Cook County.

   
 

Search current and proposed Cook County Legislation in Larry's exclusive legislative library.

   
  Cook County is the second most populous county in the nation. It is the 19th largest government in the U.S.
   
     
     
     



STD testing at jail may cost county either way
Currently suspended, the program costs county $800,000, but if lawsuits prevail, it could mean millions

Sunday, February 18, 2007
Daily Herald
by Rob Olmstead

Of all the political footballs in this year’s Cook County budget, few have been more contentious than that of testing prisoners for sexually transmitted diseases.
County Board President Todd Stroger has proposed eliminating the program — in fact, as of January, the program was suspended — while an alternative budget proposal by county commissioners would keep it in place.
Public health advocates say the program is a vital link in the health system and a way to catch a significant percentage of STD cases in Cook County.
Dr. Robert Simon, the chief of county’s bureau of health, doesn’t dispute that but says it’s a matter of prioritization.
Why, he asks, should prisoners get screened for STDs when most people going to an actual doctor’s office — private or public — don’t get that high level of care.
“Nobody screens us (unless we have symptoms),” Simon said. “So let’s look at them (prisoners) as regular citizens. Regular citizens don’t get screened when they go to a doctor.”
While those mainstay arguments on the program are hardly new, missing so far from the debate has been the role of several lawsuits against the program.
Former prisoners say they are tested against their will — that deputies line them up in cattle-call fashion and make them sign consent waivers whether they want to or not. Given the invasive nature of the test, it has inspired several prisoners to take legal action.
Even a lawyer, Lawrence Thompson, who once was detained at the jail when a judge got mad at him, has said the consent is forced, and sometimes consent cards are even signed after the test has been administered.
In December, a federal judge certified a lawsuit — Jackson v. Sheahan — against the STD testing of males at the jail for class action status, meaning that it now applies to any male who has been tested for STDs at the jail, within certain parameters.
Another lawsuit, applying to female detainees — Young v. Sheriff of Cook County — has been filed and is seeking class-action status. A ruling on the class action issue is due in April.
So far, defending against the lawsuits hasn’t broken the county’s bank. Taxpayers have paid out $29,094 to private attorneys in the Jackson lawsuit, and $33,271 in the Young case to defend the county, according to county finance committee records.
But with a dozen or so plaintiffs in Jackson seeking $100,000 each and whatever compensation a judge sees fit for the rest of the class, if the county loses the lawsuit, it could be facing a multimillion judgment for a program that costs the county just about $800,000 a year to run.
“The class is so large, you could have a very substantial result,” said Patrick Driscoll, chief of the Cook County State’s Attorney’s civil division, and the man ultimately responsible for defending the county.
The lawsuits could be a problem, but why not just fix the way the program is run rather than eliminating it, said Charlie Fasano, director of the prisons and jails program for the John Howard Association.
“Would it be problematic? Yeah. But does that mean that they should say forget it? No,” said Fasano, who monitors the jail to make sure prisoners are treated humanely and in accordance with court decrees.
Fasano said ending the testing of prisoners would end up costing the county more in the long run, as prisoners who aren’t diagnosed go back into the community to spread the disease, and then all of them show up at county health facilities.
“These people who are going back (from jail) to every part of the city or suburbs — the questions are, are they going back infected, likely to infect someone else?” Fasano asked.
Sheriff Tom Dart agreed, noting that 80 percent of people booked at the jail get back out, at least temporarily, while only about 20 percent go on directly to prison.
Kenneth Flaxman, one of the lawyers who brought the Jackson v. Sheahan lawsuit, said he thinks the program can be done in a humane way — with actual “real” consent, for example.
“But when people are tested at the jail, they don’t have a choice. The men are told drop your shorts and pull out your, well, they use a slang word that’s not fit for a family newspaper.”
All Flaxman is asking is that jail inmates get treated humanely, he said.
Dorothy Murphy-Swallows, director of the county’s STD testing program, declined an interview, saying she did not have permission from her county bosses.
But in a deposition she gave under subpoena, Murphy-Swallows noted that at one point, diagnoses at the jail accounted for one-third of all cases of certain types of STD cases in Cook County.
And, she noted, 20 percent of the men 25 and younger who are tested at the jail come back positive for some type of STD.
Simon acknowledges the program is a good one, and if he had unlimited resources, he would fund it.
But with limited resources, he has to prioritize. Even without the threat of a multimillion dollar lawsuit hanging over his head, he said, he would cut it in favor of breast cancer screenings, MRIs and colonoscopies for working poor who show up at Stroger Hospital. Right now, he noted, he has a backlog of 200 people who need hip replacements.
And as for the lawsuits?
The ever-candid Simon could barely contain his anger.
“I think it is incredible. Where’s the class-action lawsuit that represents the average citizen?”
County officials will meet several times this week to hash out a budget compromise. A vote is scheduled for Thursday.


Recent Headlines

Can courts do more to force FOID card violators to give up their guns?
Monday, February 17, 2020
Chicago Tribune

Keep the Cook County Health board independent
Sunday, February 16, 2020
Crain's Chicago Business

Park Ridge looks to move 911 dispatching services to Cook County call center
Thursday, February 13, 2020
Chicago Tribune

Editorial: A report’s flaws suggest: Cook County bail reforms may have endangered the public
Thursday, February 13, 2020
Chicago Tribune

Offering rehab instead of jail time, ‘Drug Court’ gives some a second chance
Thursday, February 13, 2020
WGN News

Preckwinkle aide barred from her offices after sexual harassment incident
Tuesday, February 11, 2020
Crain's Chicago Business

New outreach group combating Cook County’s opioid crisis by offering treatment, hope
Tuesday, February 11, 2020
WGN News

Evanston Officials Eye County Grant for Construction of New Animal Shelter
Monday, February 10, 2020
Evanston RoundTable

CTA to spend $38 million studying Red Line extension
Monday, February 10, 2020
Chicago Tribune

In Illinois — the Prairie State — little prairie land remains. But work is being done to save what’s left in Cook County and restore more.
Thursday, February 06, 2020
Chicago Tribune

Brookfield Zoo chief heads for the exits
Thursday, February 06, 2020
Crain's Chicago Business

Suspect in weekend killing of Cook County inmate accused of beating another detainee in November attack captured on video
Wednesday, February 05, 2020
Chicago Tribune

MacArthur grants Cook County another $2.5 million for criminal justice reform
Wednesday, February 05, 2020
Crain's Chicago Business

Property tax hikes won’t be that bad, new report says
Wednesday, February 05, 2020
Chicago Sun-Times

MacArthur Foundation donates $2.5 million to Cook County Criminal Courts
Wednesday, February 05, 2020
Chicago Sun-Times

Improvements planned for Green Bay Road in Evanston as part of long-term project
Tuesday, February 04, 2020
Chicago Tribune

Cook County judicial candidate Arthur Sutton has history of disciplinary issues
Tuesday, February 04, 2020
Injustice Watch

Area legislators dish on policy plans that impact seniors
Tuesday, February 04, 2020
Chicago Tribune

Pappas and other Cook County, Chicago and federal elected officials urge residents to return the 2020 Census questionnaire
Monday, February 03, 2020
Daily Herald

Plans for new Provident Hospital paused
Monday, February 03, 2020
Chicago Sun-Times

all news items

Paid for by Larry Suffredin and not at taxpayer expense. A Haymarket Production.
^ TOP